Crash and Burn 101: A Finance Professor’s Take on Our Economy
By Dr. Boyce Watkins
The United States is respected throughout the world for its powerful economy. We are also, unfortunately, becoming known for our arrogance and financial irresponsibility. During my tenure as a Visiting Scholar with the Center for European Economic Research, one of my colleagues could not understand why American consumers earn more than Germans and pay less in taxes, but have savings rates less than 20% of the average German citizen. Basically, there is a degree of irrational overconfidence and financial carelessness that comes from never having to experience a deep recession first hand. This explains why most baby boomers are not ready for retirement, and why young people spend and borrow like drunken sailors.
American consumers aren’t the only pilots in our crashing economic airplane. U.S. Monetary policy, headed by Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke, is both art and science, and the apparent success of Alan Greenspan has forced any subsequent Fed Chairman to become a Financial Da Vinci. The saddest part of the Greenspan era, however, is that his choices in the 1990s caused major “speculative bubbles” (inflated asset values in homes and stocks) that have started to burst at the end of this decade. Our leaders create and dictate policies that impact the choices of companies and consumers. Financial leadership has taken the American consumer on a frightening ride, and this is only the beginning.
The US economy saw its financial chickens coming home to roost in 2008, as the recent recession and market downturns have been predicted for years. These “financial chickens” included excessive spending by American consumers, mixed with irresponsible borrowing and lending on the part of both individuals and banks. Personal responsibility is thrown out the window when discussing wealthy and so-called “mainstream” Americans, as financial leaders are called upon to bail out the banks, the consumers and everyone else.
The government bailout package for 2008 has, thus far, included a massive spending bill, one that featured tax refunds and support to help consumers keep their homes, even if they were the causes of their own demise. Another set of “financial steroids” being employed have been the strong and consistent cuts of the Federal Funds rate by Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke. Bernanke has become known as “Bold Ben” by members of the media, who are consistently stunned by the Chairman’s massive and powerful attempts to control the economic downturn. The latest moves have included the $85 Billion dollar bailout of AIG, an insurance company that has apparently been deemed “too large to fail”. If only our government had the same compassion for the thousands of small businesses across America struggling to find capital to meet short-term financing needs.
Republicans, known for being fiscally responsible, have created budget deficits our country has never seen. Between the Iraq War and the 2008 recession, spending continues to go up, even when tax revenues are expected to go down. The ready availability of additional government borrowing to support our massive spending bills has our financial leaders behaving like teenagers in possession of a “really awesome” American Express card. Like the “blinged out” athlete who thinks his wallet will never be empty, our country may wake up to a grave financial nightmare.
Continuously cutting interest rates may provide additional stimulation to the economy, but the problem is that cutting interest rates, allowing the value of the dollar to slide and frivolous government spending is a recipe for serious, horrific and uncontrollable inflation. Inflation is a Pandora’s Box that doesn’t close nearly as easily as it opens. You think the economy is bad now, you haven’t seen how bad it can get in the face of stagflation (a declining economy with out of control inflation). It’s hard not to feel that “Bold Ben” and “Big Bad Bush” aren’t gambling with our children’s futures and current taxpayer resources.
Sometimes, when you party too hard, you are forced to deal with the hangover. Americans have been blessed with a financial celebration that has lasted over a decade. For the past 15 years, we drank straight out of the liquor bottle and danced with lamp shades on our heads: not saving effectively, spending like crazy and borrowing to cover our financial insanity. But rather than simply allowing the party to end and letting everyone sober up, our financial leadership has taken on the irresponsible behavioral norms of American consumers. Their excessive rate cuts and spending increases have kept us pumped up on Financial Dope in order to avoid the impending crash.
This is not solid financial leadership, and something has GOT to give. Hopefully our leaders will get it.
Dr. Boyce Watkins is a Finance Professor at Syracuse University and author of “Financial Lovemaking 101: Merging Assets with Your Partner in Ways that Feel Good.” He is a regular commentator in national media, including CNN, CBS, NBC, BET and ESPN. For more information, please visit www.BoyceWatkins.net or DrBoyceFinance.WordPress.com.
Loading...
This article has put in perspective the magnitude of our economy’s situation. There seems to be numerous, compounding issues and factors which will come crashing down like a tidal wave on our financial system, if our leaders, corporations, and consumers do not take respondsibility for their financial wrecklessness. We all must address these issues and may have to cut back and take losses in order for the financial system to regain some footing to avoid crashing.
What I am most concerned about, especially for us finance majors, is how is this financial instability going to affect our job search and employment prospects?
With the influx of potential employees into the job market from Lehman Brothers and other financial firms, how much more difficult will it be to find a job post-graduation?
andrewrobinson01 - September 18, 2008 at 3:52 am
I just read another article regarding the financial system mess prior to this one and it mentioned that although the financial crisis has been an issue, it has not had a significant effect on the rest of the economy yet. The prospects of an even larger economic crisis existing outside of the financial system could very much happen in the near future due to this credit mess. To make the situation even worse for the typical American person, the recent bailouts of major firms like AIG and Bear Sterns as well as the billions of dollars the government has already pumped into the situation, coupled with increases in military spending, will create major tax burdens for U.S. citizens in the future.
mikemiranda113 - September 18, 2008 at 4:27 am
This economic crisis will have global consequences and many countries are going to suffer from this as well. Hopefully our next leader is smart enough to start making some changes and taking this seriously. Our futures are going to be affected by this crisis and getting a job is going to get even harder.
rodbustam - September 18, 2008 at 1:47 pm
I can honestly admit that I am scared. I was born at the end of one financial crisis, but never really felt the impacts of something economically severe as of yet. Granted, this crisis hasn’t exactly reached the consumer per se, and I say that very loosely, which is acctually even more scary because consumers still feel complacent in their situation and are just waiting for the higher ups to do something about it.
My question is, what can we, consumers, do to help? Or at least protect ourselves from personal financial disasters?
charlesthomas87 - September 19, 2008 at 6:19 pm
It seems as though Robert Kiyoskai may have been correct in his book Prophecy Theory…about a coming colapse…That is a bit scary… Have any of you read it? I Hope it is not comming to pass, but who knows?
Does anyone want to comment?
All my best,
Miles Cobbett
milescobbett - September 20, 2008 at 11:31 pm
Good perspective. The consistent ability (or stupidity?) of the American consumer to spend beyond our means will make weathering this storm very difficult for the average family.
If you do not have savings you will get burned. Unfortunately we (families) are not too large to fail so any bailout will be too little too late for us.
Good Luck All!
Cliff Davis CPA
cdaviscpa - September 21, 2008 at 2:45 am
Sadly the US will drag many other countries down with it and in the process it allows China and a select few to rise with even more dominance. Given the Chinese track record on human rights, scams, fake, environmental disregard, etc this is scary.
In allowing the monetary system to drive unfettered for many years and in encouraging people to “spend up large”, often on junk, we in the Western World have handed China the World “on a plate”.
bs1999bs - September 21, 2008 at 4:48 am
There is always a payoff after sweet. People in the U.S. know how to enjoy their lives when they have money and never think about their future. Now, there are more and more people consider about saving, because of the poor economy we have now. Is it too late to save? Or maybe this is just another start or a lesson that people in the U.S. should learn about how they should control their budget.
huali22 - September 21, 2008 at 6:02 pm
Another amazing aspect to this entire financial fiasco is that the majority of people my age don’t seem to understand the true magnitude of what is happening. Everyone knows that the stock market and the economy as a whole is struggling but they don’t understand to any degree what is causing this or the possible effects on our lives. I must admit, even as a finance major I only have a superficial understanding of everything that is going on so it comes as no surprise to me that I have had numerous people say something along the lines of “Hey Zack you’re a finance major right, can you explain to me what’s going on with the stock market, it seems really important and I want to know what’s going on but I don’t understand any of the news coverage.” As a country we just need to have a better understanding of the basics of finance or else we will continue to get ourselves into trouble like we have right now
zackpien - September 22, 2008 at 1:16 am
Precisely! You have done an excellent job at summarizing the events that have lead to the recent downslide of our economy and I love the metaphors you used, they really “hit home” for us college students.
Jazelle Reed - September 23, 2008 at 3:33 am